A little bit louder?

I’ve really been enjoying the Scrappy Trip-Along quilt, especially seeing all the other pictures in the flickr group — it’s great to see the different color and fabric choices!

I’ve been planning on making my quilt 8×8, to be a (really large) queen size with plenty of drape, with a narrow solid border around the edges, and a plain binding. But I laid out the blocks I have right now, all 48 of them, and now I’m on the fence. I think 8×8 might be too large!

 

I’m considering three things and I would love opinions: please weigh in!
— 6×8 with a 6″ border = roughly 81″ x 104″ Concern: I worry that 81″ x 104″ is lopsided.
— 8×8 and a 4″ border = a neat 100″ x 100″ Concern: I worry that this is too big!
— 7×7 with a 6″ border = 92″ x 92″ Concern: I have an irrational dislike of odd numbers.

 

I laid the blocks I already have finished and trimmed out on my kitchen floor (after moving the kitchen table out of the way). This is what I had to do to get a picture of the whole thing:
me-ladder-cropped

That’s an 8 foot ladder. But from the top of it, I got this picture:
6x8-before1

And after moving some squares around a little bit, I got this one:
6x8-after1

I tested the layout in black and white, and I think it’s almost right:
6x8-after bw

This quilt is going to be a gift, and I want it to be something the recipients can really use, not something that’s just not quite right. So I have to make up my mind: 6×8? 7×7? Or 8×8? Let me know what you think — please!

I have the fabric all cut for the other blocks, so the time or work involved in making the next blocks is absolutely not a concern: I want this to be as good a gift as it can be, not something I think about later and wonder “what if?”

7 Replies to “A little bit louder?”

  1. Lovely quilt, I know the recipients will treasure it. Since my vote is alone so far, I’ve got 100% for my view! I vote go large, then they can use it and have lots of room to turn over and not pull it off!

  2. I know 8X8 seems huge but here is my rationale: I have a queen bed, but I put a King size comforter on it because I like extra drape and lots of comforter. You mentioned up above that you want a really large queen with plenty of drape – so I would say 8X8. This also allows for turning back the top portion to show the awesome back or the alternative of making up the bed old school style so it can go all the way to the head of the bed covering up the under pillows. Now the fun part – I love the way you are laying it out according to values! And I am enjoying the acrobatics on ladders involved in this quilt. I am pretty sure no matter how you finish this – the recipient is going to love it!

  3. I don’t think the 6×8 looks lopsided, at least in your pictures. Do you know how the recipient is likely to use it? If you are pretty sure they’ll use it on their bed, then obviously match the bedding size as closely as you can. But if it’s a large snuggle quilt, then I think you have a bit more freedom in what you choose. I’d probably lean toward the 6×8, personally. Another thing you can do is see how large other blankets/quilts you have are, and use that for a test run. If you’ve got something close to 100″x100″, try it out on the couch and see if it’s unwieldy as a snuggle quilt. Personally, I like having way more quilt than I need, and don’t understand the idea of a “lap quilt” but that’s just me. :)

  4. I’m visiting from WIP Wednesday–love your TAL! I think your 6×8 layout looks fine. If you want to enlarge it for bed quilt purposes, sure, sure–but I made a big, big 100-ishx100-ish scrappy quilt that doesn’t get much use because it is just much too big for us to use every day. My vote is 6×8, I think, will enter above!

  5. I am a big believer that bigger is better. I’ve made a few “queen” quilts for my bed but they never seem to be big enough. I like them to hang over on both sides and not just cover the top of the mattress. But I’m not usually a fan of square quilts so maybe the 6 x 8?

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s